Do you charge for design consultations?

Yes. One reviewer paid $400 for a 40-minute design consultation; rates not stated elsewhere.

Are you available in Wilton, Weston, or Westport?

Yes. The business is based in Wilton and operates throughout southern Fairfield County, with a network of licensed subcontractors in the Wilton/Weston/Westport area.

Can you handle older homes that need problem-solving?

Yes. Reviewers highlight Andy's ability to diagnose difficult issues, anticipate problems in period homes, and deliver specialized period restoration work.

Benchmark Builders, LLC

Updated 2026-10-03 · 45,223 reviewed · 807 listed · Scored from 44 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.9(44) 72 low data composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified

Historic Masonry RestorationBrick MasonryChimney Masonry & RepairPatios, Walkways & Hardscaping

Google-verified44 Google reviewssince 1987

Location: Wilton
Services: Historic Masonry Restoration, Brick Masonry, Chimney Masonry & Repair
Reviews: 44
Ranking: #191 in Historic Masonry Restoration
Best for: homeowners undertaking kitchen, bathroom, or masonry repairs in Fairfield County

Business data from Google Business Profile, checked 2026-10-03. Facts from the business's own website were fetched 2026-09-07.

What recent reviews say

Benchmark Builders earns consistent five-star ratings for kitchen and bathroom renovations, with reviewers praising Andy Payne's clear communication and detail-focused approach. One complaint flagged a $400 design fee and steep estimates, though that client later completed work at 60% of their quote.

Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.

Praised for

responsive communication
attention to detail
on-time delivery
skilled craftsmanship
honest pricing and transparency

Watch-outs

design consultation charges
high estimates

skilled-craftsmanshipresponsive-quotespunctualclean-worksiteattention-to-detaildurable-workexperienced-crewreliable-schedulingresidential-homeownersfair-pricing

Best for: homeowners undertaking kitchen, bathroom, or masonry repairs in Fairfield County

Think twice if: design consultations carry a fee; get a clear scope and budget upfront to avoid sticker shock on estimates

Where this business shines

Owner-led projects with personal oversight
Anticipates problems before they arise
Skilled network of licensed subcontractors
Transparent line-item breakdowns

Worth knowing

Andy Payne is the owner and general contractor who leads projects personally
Licensed Connecticut contractor (HIC #0565131) and lead-safe certified
Describes subcontractors as professional, expedient, and respectful
Handles water damage, siding repair, framing, chimney work, egress doors, and period restoration
Reviewers note he anticipates and mitigates surprises on old-house work

What reviews say by service

Brick Masonry: Reviewers mention chimney framing and masonry work handled alongside larger renovations; no standalone masonry-only reviews.
Chimney Masonry & Repair: Reviewer noted framing around chimney addressed during siding repair project.
Patios, Walkways & Hardscaping: Deck building and design praised for craftsmanship and waterproofing solutions.

How it compares

Rated 4.9 against a 4.74 average across the 315 historic masonry restoration businesses listed here.
Has more Google reviews than 90% of the businesses in this directory.

What earned this score?

Ranking Method

Star rating 87

Review volume 72

Review recency 59

Review sentiment 60

Profile completeness 75

Verification 30

Rating breakdown

Common questions

Do you charge for design consultations?: Yes. One reviewer paid $400 for a 40-minute design consultation; rates not stated elsewhere.
Are you available in Wilton, Weston, or Westport?: Yes. The business is based in Wilton and operates throughout southern Fairfield County, with a network of licensed subcontractors in the Wilton/Weston/Westport area.
Can you handle older homes that need problem-solving?: Yes. Reviewers highlight Andy's ability to diagnose difficult issues, anticipate problems in period homes, and deliver specialized period restoration work.

Request a quote

Similar masonry contractors nearby

50 low data

Langner Renovations Alterations Decks LLC

5.0(2)

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Brick Masonry

View profile

67 low data

J&M H0me Improvement

5.0(4)✓ Google-verified

All four five-star reviews praise J&M's attention to detail, on-time scheduling, and clean work areas. Jairo is named across multiple reviews as responsive and skilled at turning ideas into finished work. Kitchen cabinets and countertops are the primary services mentioned.

Historic Masonry RestorationBrick Masonry

View profile