Connecticut Masonry Contractor Guide
Menu
Start your project

Nutmeg Roofing Company

Updated 2026-09-07 · 10,764 reviewed · 659 listed · Scored from 69 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.7(69) 77 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Brick MasonryChimney Masonry & RepairConcrete & Flatwork

Google-verified69 Google reviews

Nutmeg Roofing Company
Location
Orange
Services
Brick Masonry, Chimney Masonry & Repair, Concrete & Flatwork
Reviews
69
Ranking
#89 in Brick Masonry
Best for
Homeowners needing quick storm damage or emergency roof repairs with insurance coordination.

Business data from Google Business Profile, checked 2026-09-07.

What recent reviews say

Most customers praise Nutmeg's speed, responsiveness, and repair quality, especially for emergency work like storm damage and ice dams. Sonny and crew members like Chris handle estimates and coordinate with insurers smoothly.

However, two serious complaints emerge: one detailed dispute over a $26,000 pergola roof built flat with no drainage (causing pooling water and structural damage), and another about a 2-hour scheduling miss with hostile follow-up. These outliers suggest execution gaps on complex builds and communication lapses when problems arise.

Praised for
  • fast response and scheduling
  • skilled repair work
  • strong communication
  • thorough cleanup
  • handles insurance coordination
Watch-outs
  • poor design execution on major jobs
  • scheduling delays and misrepresentation
  • unresponsive to complaints
  • deflects responsibility
responsive-quotespunctualskilled-craftsmanshipclean-worksitepoor-communicationmissed-deadlines
Best for: Homeowners needing quick storm damage or emergency roof repairs with insurance coordination.
Think twice if: Families planning large custom builds should clarify design details and drainage in writing before work starts; get disputes resolved in writing.

Where this business shines

  • answers calls directly
  • same-day or next-day estimates and repairs
  • handles insurance claims coordination
  • works nights and weekends for emergencies

Worth knowing

  • Sonny Mitchell is the owner and primary contact
  • Chris is a crew member who handles inspections, estimates, and foreman duties
  • offers same-day emergency response (e.g., Saturday ice dam repair)
  • includes gutter cleaning and yard cleanup as courtesy work
  • staff worked into the night during blizzard
  • roof completed in as little as 1.5 days

What reviews say by service

Chimney Masonry & Repair
Chimney flashing repairs praised as fast and reliable.
Concrete & Flatwork
Stamped asphalt driveway repair called excellent and thorough, restoring cracked surface to like-new condition.

How it compares

  • Rated 4.7 against a 4.82 average across the 155 chimney masonry & repair businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 95% of the businesses in this directory.

What earned this score?

Ranking Method
Star rating 79
Review volume 80
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 50
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
64
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
5

Common questions

Can you do emergency repairs on weekends or after hours?
Yes. The owner picked up the phone for a Saturday ice-dam emergency, worked into the night, and completed the repair before a blizzard.
Do you handle insurance claims?
Yes. Chris coordinates with insurance companies and claims adjusters, handling the paperwork and process explanation.
How long does a typical roof replacement take?
One customer had a full replacement done in 1.5 days. Another roof was completed 3 days after the estimate and contract signing.
Request a quote

Similar masonry contractors nearby

Total Chimney Care LLC
91

Total Chimney Care LLC

4.8(232)✓ Google-verified

Technicians consistently show up on schedule, work neatly, and explain what they're doing every step. Reviewers praise the crew for being friendly and honest about what needs fixing, plus the clean worksite when done. One reviewer specifically noted receiving a technician photo, which eased trust concerns about letting a stranger in. The business handles chimney sweeps, inspections, relining, repairs, fireplace work, damper and cap installation, leak sealing, flashing, and dryer vent cleaning. Staff ground and recememt joints, apply sealers, and install caps. They've earned certification from the Chimney Safety Institute of America and National Chimney Sweep Guild training since 1996.

Chimney Masonry & RepairBrick MasonryHistoric Masonry Restoration
View profile
Oaklands Roofing & Masonry
66 low data

Oaklands Roofing & Masonry

5.0(3)✓ Google-verified

Owner brings deep technical expertise and a crew that shows up every day until work is done. Initial contact can be slow and address info needs verification, but quality and commitment win repeat jobs.

Brick MasonryHistoric Masonry RestorationChimney Masonry & Repair
View profile
Paulo Masonry LLC
57 low data

Paulo Masonry LLC

4.2(5)✓ Google-verified

Most jobs earn strong praise for quality retaining walls and reasonable rates, with work completed quickly. One recent repair exposed gaps: forgotten stone slabs, a corner left unfinished, and a price dispute afterward raised concerns about small-job care and clarity.

Historic Masonry RestorationPatios, Walkways & HardscapingBrick Masonry
View profile

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-09-07